The myth of the Chiemgau impact

or what R. Huber, K. Lauterbach and R. Darga omit in their article in MAPS

The myth of the Chiemgau impact and the actual origins of the landforms according to Huber, Lauterbach and Darga – and what the authors forgot to mention.


The open-access article by Huber, Lauterbach and Darga, published in the latest issue of the journal Meteoritics and Planetary Science, with peer reviewers W.-U. Reimold and M. Boslough, and editor C. Koeberl, is of such a low standard that it was never expected from the renowned journal of the Meteoritical Society.

The authors: a former marine geologist and current research data manager, a private individual not involved in science, and the well-known Ice Age geologist, who have never themselves worked on, let alone published on, meteoritic impacts and impact research topics such as impact geology, impact geophysics, impact mineralogy/petrography, impact geochemistry, shock metamorphism, impact crater formation, or impact fracture mechanics.

Their article is currently the latest milestone in an almost 20-year history of bitter, sometimes polemical, attempts to portray the world’s most significant Chiemgau impact event of the Holocene as non-existent and a myth. The fact that some impact databases continue to ignore this makes the matter neither better nor more convincing.

A very brief commentary article by K. Ernstson and J. Poßekel can be found here and on ResearchGate . There, a list of 55 (fifty-five) publications by the researchers on the Chiemgau impact is also included, most of which are clickable.

Chiemgau impact hypothesis – the English Wikipedia Opinion Machine

Although brief, the entry on the Chiemgau impact on Wikipedia reveals the site to be a platform for opinion with a biased and partisan administrator. We will also keep this brief and refer readers to the website, which contains a list of approximately 45 contributions on the current state of scientific research into what is likely the most significant impact event of the Holocene to date. These papers (mostly to be downloaded) appeared in internationally renowned journals and were published as peer-reviewed papers at the Lunar & Planetary Science Conferences, the Meteoritical Society Meetings, and the Fall Meetings of the American Geophysical Union.

Chiemgau impact: Wikipedia ad absurdum

Chiemgau impact: Wikipedia has mutated to a manipulation machine, initiated by well-known scribblers and opponents of the Chiemgau Impact who remain unrepentant to this day.

The term “Chiemgau Impact” refers to a disproved hypothesis concerning the impact of a comet or asteroid that is said to have exploded after entering Earth’s atmosphere, with its debris allegedly falling in the Chiemgau region. The impact is said to have occurred between 2200 and 300 BCE.[1] [2]

The hypothesis regarding the existence of a Chiemgau impact, first proposed by amateur archaeologists in 2000, has since been refuted by several independent studies in the fields of geology (sediment analysis), botany (pollen analysis), and dating (radiocarbon method).[3][4] [5]

Studies that contradict the Chiemgau impact hypothesis

The hypothesis of an extraterrestrial impact in the Chiemgau region, first proposed at the beginning of the century, has not yet been confirmed. Several independent studies consider the hypothesis to be refuted.

Gerhard Doppler and Erwin Geiss, geologists at the Bavarian State Office for the Environment (LfU), concluded in 2005, following a field survey of Lake Tüttensee and the surrounding area, that the interpretation of the lake as an impact crater is extremely unlikely. [6] …..

… and more old as dirt rubbish … enabled by the biased Wikipedia operator.

To return to the truth, click here.

Matthias Köpf from the SZ: a “commentary” on the Chiemgau impact

By chance, I (K.E.) came across this article from October 2025 (!) in the Süddeutsche Zeitung (SZ) newspaper today:

https://www.sueddeutsche.de/bayern/chiemgau-tuettensee-meteoritenkrater-li.3322897

My comment: I haven’t read a more stupid article about our impact in a long time – and that in the SZ. Not a glorious moment for the SZ! It reads as if R. Darga guided the journalist’s pen. According to the article, Matthias Köpf is from Grabenstätt. Perhaps he should visit the town hall there and the Impact Museum in the Schloßökonomie.

But this fits in perfectly with the latest very informative article written by H.-P. Matheisl from KI, which can be clicked on here:

https://www.chiemgau-impact.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/13.2.-Chiemgau-Finale-Dokumentation-en-US.pdf

The Chiemgau impact and the Digital Terrain Model DGM 1

Article Part 3: the larger-sized craters

Continuing our description with a summary of the impact inventory of the Chiemgau strewn field (Part 2, Part 1) we present here the third part, which is again published on the science portals Researchgate and Academia as as preprint. The article can be downloaded here as a PDF file (click on the title):
The Chiemgau Impact (Germany) meteorite crater strewn field and the role of Digital Terrain Models. – Model craters, Part 3: the large craters – Lake Brunnensee/Griessee crater, Lake Obing crater, the Tittmoning (Asten, Leitgering) craters, Lake Chiemsee multiple crater, Eglsee crater, Lake Eschenau and Lake Laubensee craters, Lake Bärnsee crater, Lake Tüttensee crater ensemble. – K. Ernstson and J. Poßekel


The Chiemgau impact and the Digital Terrain Model DGM 1

Article Part 2: the medium-sized c

Article Part 2: the medium-sized craters

Continuing our description with a summary of the impact inventory of the Chiemgau strewn field (Part 1), we present here the second part, which is again published on the science portal Researchgate as a preprint. The article can be downloaded here as a PDF file (click on the title):

The Chiemgau Impact (Germany) meteorite crater strewn field and the role of Digital Terrain Models. – Model craters, Part 2: the Bergham, Riederting, Seeon, Natural-Monument, Purkering and Windschnur medium-sized craters by Kord Ernstson and Jens Poßekel

The start image above shows a topographic map and terrain surface of the digital terrain model DGM 1 for the natural monument at the Seeon horse farm, which has always been listed in maps and descriptions as a typical dead ice hole from the last ice age and is listed by the Bavarian State Office for the Environment (LfU) as a geotope particularly worth seeing.

The DGM 1 symbolizes a necessary rethinking of the LfU’s Bavarian ice age research, which continues to adhere to a dead ice hypothesis that has never been scientifically or geologically substantiated, with countless so-called dead ice holes and their designation as geotopes, which was recently documented in an article and can be seen as an example of scientific falsification by the LfU in the case of the Tüttensee meteorite crater.

2 contributions to the AGU Conference 2025

The following two iPosters have been accepted for presentation at the renowned American Geophysical Union conference in New Orleans in December. The abstract announcements can now be downloaded:

K. Ernstson & J. Poßekel: High-resolution Digital Terrain Models (DTM): a new approach to impact cratering

K. Ernstson & J. Poßekel: Geophysics of the Lake Tüttensee meteorite crater ensemble (Chiemgau impact strewn field, Germany)

Each year, AGU’s annual meeting, the largest gathering of Earth and space scientists, convenes 25,000+ attendees from 100+ countries to share research and connect with friends and colleagues. Scientists, educators, policymakers, journalists and communicators attend AGU25 to better understand our planet and environment, opening pathways to discovery, opening greater awareness to address climate change, opening greater collaborations to lead to solutions and opening the fields and professions of science to a whole new age of justice equity, diversity, inclusion and belonging.

Ice Age, dead ice, meteorite impact, and the digital terrain model

The complete article can be downloaded here as a PDF file:

***********************************

The Schlitzer Kauten (Hesse) and the high-resolution Digital Terrain Model DGM 1: an airburst impact event with a crater strewn field

Kord Ernstson, Jens Poßekel and Rudolf Auth